Tue 21 Nov 2006
Week 11: Jaguars 26 — Giants 10
Posted by Greg under UncategorizedI intentionally stalled a little before writing this post, figuring that my anger/ disappointment would abate somewhat so that I could approach this with some degree of lucidity. But no such luck. It’s late, I’m pissed, and it’s hard to imagine how I’m gonna shake this off in time to get to sleep at the much celebrated “reasonable hour.”
By tomorrow, you’ll be reading this at work, semi-refreshed, having slept on this disgraceful performance and put it in a more healthy perspective than the one I have now. There will probably be people, things, and tasks in your office that are bothering you more than Eli’s 19-41, 2 interception performance, which is actually a very flattering representation of his night.
For the sixth game in a row, the guy was bad. But tonight was the worst of them all – indeed, this was as bad as I can remember seeing a quarterback play. And because he was under so much scrutiny this week, tonight’s performance was particularly disappointing. In a big spot, in a big game, when he was under the microscope, Eli wilted.
But does this make him a wilter? No. Please, let’s hold off on those types of character assassinations. After all, we know from his track record of 4th quarter performances that they guy has a certain degree of mental fortitude.
But right now Elisha is lost – in terms of mechanics, confidence, and the trust of his teammates (who all seemed to be getting progressively more pissed over the course of the night). At this point, it’s fair to say that Eli is single-handedly dragging the offense down. None of the Giants will say this in any press conference, but the fact is, the pass protection was just fine tonight and the receivers didn’t drop any passes. Obviously, the running game struggled, which is a mitigating factor, but if Eli had even an average game, the Giants would have been firmly in the game (which, weirdly, they actually were until about 10 minutes left in the fourth quarter, when Eli threw that unconscionable pick to that linebacker Ingram, who was camped in front of Plax, and then the Jags kicked a field goal to go up by 16.)
But as it happened, Eli continued to bury them, and they wound up pretty much getting blown out. The 26-10 score doesn’t do justice to the degree of ass-whoopage that took place. And because the Giants accumulated a good deal of garbage-time yards, the end-of-game stats don’t really either. But anyway, on the night, the Jags had 414 yards to our 247. They had only 1 turnover (the Taylor play, which, like, really should have been a touchdown!) to our 3 (which were all very well-deserved, and infuriating). Most telling of all, they had the ball for 40 minutes to our 20. That’s like some Super Bowl XXV shit! But alas, with the way Eli has been playing, we, umm… don’t have that old Bills offense.
Ok, I’m done for now. I’ll have more to say tomorrow. Bad loss. This type of effort will not do.
November 21st, 2006 at 10:18 am
Eli is Dave Brown but with a better supporting cast. Giving away the store to get him, simply because his last name is Manning, is going to haunt us for 10 years. I think he has the makings of an adequate NFL QB — someone who, had he been picked in the 3rd round, would be a pleasant surprise to a team and its fans. But he is not a big-time QB and nothing is going to make him one. And we’re stuck with him.
November 21st, 2006 at 1:28 pm
Is it me, or did Eli not even look like he wanted to be on the field last night? His whole performance was half-hearted, from his casual mechanics to his demeanor on the sidelines. Weird. Makes you wonder if he’s been playing football all these years because that’s what his whole family does/thinks about/talks about/lives for, and he’s just beginning to realize he doesn’t really love the game that much. And then he’s gonna come out of the closet. You watch.
November 21st, 2006 at 1:40 pm
Not that it mattered, but how ridiculously bad are the NFL refs? How did they miss Tim Carter getting mounted, ridden, and also face-masked on what should have been a 40/50-yard completion?
November 23rd, 2006 at 10:42 am
Curious, what’s your take on Tiki’s latest tirade? I’m firming the Vacarro’s camp: http://www.nypost.com/seven/11232006/sports/giants/throwing_knives_is_no_shock_giants_mike_vaccaro.htm
There’s nothing in this rant that helps the team. Hope to see Coughlin fire back, both barrels, with the game stats. Cannot run if it’s 3 and out everytime. I think every fan is questioning the gameplan, but the point is team leaders don’t throw members of the family under the bus. Tiki does. I’ll miss his talent, but will never pay a bit of attention to anyone he does once he departs the Meadowlands.
November 24th, 2006 at 2:31 pm
Anything that diverts the spotlight away from Eli right now is a good thing.
November 26th, 2006 at 6:11 pm
This is on par with the SF playoff loss. Awful. Bad call on Walker personal foul, regardless of what TV idiot said. It was at the marker, players trying to prevent the first down. Plax sucks. And wtf happened on that “sack”? I assume he thought the ball was away, was trying to avoid another 15 yarder. And that whiny bitch did nothing in the second half, when Coughlin called his number to grind out the clock. Awful
November 26th, 2006 at 6:39 pm
That’s enough for me. Today’s loss to the Titans, arguably the worst loss in the history of the franchise, cements my decision that Coughin needs to go. Fire Goughlin Now.
November 26th, 2006 at 6:40 pm
Craig is 100% right on the call on Walker — that call was a disgrace. Young was still in bounds and still heading forward, two yards short of the first down, when Walker put a clean hit on him. It’s ridiculous how much these BS calls are allowed to change games.
And all of these light calls on the QBs are the reason Nuke let up on Young — he thought the ball had already been thrown. Considering how often they give 15 yards for perfectly clean hits on QBs, you can’t blame him.
November 26th, 2006 at 6:53 pm
Oh my god.
Oh god.
Vomit.